10/08/2014

IN TAMESIDE, DEMOCRACY IS IN LOCK- DOWN

It is said that men in North Korea used to be able to style their hair in any way they wished, but now they can choose only one, that of their leader Kim Jong Un.

Not to be outdone and in an effort not to deviate one iota from the controlling ways of the young Korean dictator, Tameside council bosses, have adopted a strict political strategy, strikingly similar to that of Kim Jong Un, and as a first strike, have allegedly decreed that all civil servants working on Tameside council computers will be denied the right to access the thoughts of certain 'political bloggers' in an effort to subvert and control access to opposing political opinions and block access to legitimate bloggers who frequently engage in the questioning of the Labour dominated council decisions.

If true, this draconian diktat is tantamount to political censorship and flies in the face of the latest UK Government statement that they support access to the open Internet. In particular the adherence to the openness principle both for fixed and mobile access to the Internet, whereby consumers should always have the ability to access any legal content or service.

That being the case; by councillors blocking council workers access to free-speech; such restrictions are clearly verging on violations of their rights. Surely, the council has no right to censor protected speech on the Internet, and it cannot reduce adults to hearing and seeing only speech and opinions that the council considers suitably in concert with their particular views.

Put simply, democracy itself; the whole notion of an engaged citizenry holding their councillors to account, is potentially being denied to the very people who work for them and who may have also voted for them.

Apparently these poor dears who on the face of it ask us for our opinion and frequently say they participate in ‘public consultation’, actually only want praise. And anyone who dares to question or openly pass judgment on council actions is censored!

This situation highlights the dangers of the mindset that can come with a long period in power, only listening to those who agree with you.

My advice to these poor souls is if you can't cope, you should leave the work to someone who can.

I'm not listening!
When someone brings a legitimate mistake to your attention, don’t get on the defensive and start making excuses for it. You are supposed to be mature councillors; take responsibility for your actions. By blocking out criticism you are acting like those spoilt brats, who stand in the corner with their fingers in their ears, shouting “I’m not listening!” 

By adopting that attitude, you will be stuck in eternal mediocrity because you will never accept the need for improvement.

Remember, while denying your mistakes, and blaming others, you may be able to keep the heat off for the moment, but eventually the truth will out!

As a reminder to Labour Councillor Kieran Quinn and the rest of his apparatchiks, debate and dissent are supposed to be important parts of your national political tradition; in fact, if you read your own party’s history, it’s what Labour was born out of.

As Michael Foot once said: “Is the Labour Party to remain a democratic party in which the right of free criticism and free debate is not merely tolerated but encouraged? Or are the rank and file of the party to be bludgeoned or cowed into an uncritical subservience towards the leadership?”

In Tameside it would seem it’s the latter! If Ed Miliband is serious about plans to reform and to open up and democratise Labour's relationship with individual members, Tameside's council chamber might be a good place to start!

7 comments:

  1. This is serious news indeed Curmudgeon. As far as I am aware both you and I have never published falsehood or lies about anyone, thought we have both published facts which "They" would prefer to remain hidden from sight as well as pertinent comment on issues of concern to the public. The same can be said of other blogs in the Tameside area besides ours.

    I regard bloggers, or "Citizen Journalists" as some call them, as the last line of defence of free speech and democratic accountability in many towns and cities where the local media is no longer independent but in the grip or control of local business or political parties.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Excellent post, as usual. I do wonder if I happen to be on that, so called hit list, as I had a meeting with my superiors on Friday afternoon, after Tameside Council complained about me!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Why does this not surprise me in the least! Keep up the good work Curmudgeon.

    ReplyDelete
  4. If you say anything against TMBC on twitter or one of their many twitter accounts you're blocked instantly.
    You can use any of my images at https://twitter.com/GeeCrossRT
    Just added Kim Jong Quinn

    ReplyDelete
  5. Northern Voices8/12/2014 7:41 pm

    Very interesting story Curmudgeon but what's your evidence to back this up? You say "Tameside have allegedly decreed" and "if true", but this is hardly concrete evidence. We know for previous reports in Private Eye that there have been attempts by TMBC to censor certain news stories and they have been caught out. But I had no trouble accessing your blog today or the Tameside Citizen blog from a computer in a Tameside library.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. On receiving your comments I made further inquiries from a source who has legitimate access to the internet from a computer 'within the Town Hall' and access was denied to both Curmudgeon and the Tameside Citizen blog, whilst access could be gained to other local bloggers! Ergo, my comments stand.

      Delete
  6. This kind of censorship in Tameside may be more widespread than many people realise. I've just tried to acccess the blog of 'Tameside Unemployed Workers' Alliance' from a public library in Tameside and I was denied access, by Tameside Council. No doubt the council are banning many other sites that are critical of them?

    ReplyDelete

Please feel free to comment and express your views, all opinions are welcome but we will not post comments that contain abusive language or are deemed to be offensive or inflammatory.